3Intellectual Property Insights from Fishman Stewart
Newsletter – Volume 26, Issue 26
Share on Social

Settle the Mark: Using Mediation to Resolve Trademark Disputes Before They Escalate
A letter arrives. A lawyer claims that your trademark looks too much like his client’s and demands that you stop. You have spent years building that brand. Now what? Giving in risks the identity you have built; going to war turns the disagreement into a fight neither business may want. A contested case can end with a registration declared invalid, the scope of your rights narrowed, or a finding that makes the next dispute harder to win. But those are not the only choices. A third path is to sit down with a neutral third party and resolve a different question: does this trademark dispute really need a verdict or can both businesses keep using their names without confusing customers?
When that is the central question, mediation offers a way to work out what space each business needs. A mediator is a trained neutral who helps the two sides talk but, unlike a judge, cannot force them to accept a resolution, so the parties stay in the driver’s seat.
Mediation can happen at almost any stage, and as a rule the earlier the better, because positions are softer and legal bills are smaller. It can come right after the initial demand letter, before anyone has filed anything. It can also happen once a challenge is underway at the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board (TTAB), the part of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office that hears disputes over whether a trademark should be registered or cancelled. If the dispute has reached federal court, many judges encourage the parties to try mediation.
Each forum also offers its own settlement tools. The TTAB will pause its case schedule to allow time for settlement efforts. Opposing parties at the TTAB may also select Accelerated Case Resolution, or “ACR,” a faster alternative to a typical Board proceeding.¹
Turning to the courts, some run court-annexed mediation programs, and some offer early neutral evaluation, in which a neutral gives the parties a candid, non-binding read on the strengths and weaknesses of their positions.
What does a happy ending look like? Usually, it is a coexistence agreement: something like a property-line agreement between neighbors, spelling out who gets to do what and where. Start with the boundaries: the goods and services allocated to each company, the regions or sales channels where each will operate, and the appearance of logos and packaging so customers do not mix the two up. Then address cooperation: what the companies will do if confusion arises and whether the agreement includes granting consent to registration of their respective marks. Finally, plan for change and disagreement: how the businesses can grow, what happens if a company is sold or licenses its brand, and what happens if someone breaks the deal. Vague boundaries and silence about those future events can undermine the peace the agreement is meant to create.
Recent cases have asked the question about what the result should be when the trademarks of both parties are alike but there appears to be no likelihood of confusion. See, for example, Pepperdine University v. Netflix, Inc.² in which Pepperdine University had used the mark, “Waves,” since its founding in 1937 to designate its sports teams. The dispute was triggered when Netflix began hosting and streaming “Running Point” about a fictional basketball franchise named the “Los Angeles Waves.” In addition to the identical name, the Los Angeles Waves uses a mark similar to that used by the Pepperdine WAVES on its jerseys, shirts, stadium, advertising, etc. What do you think happened? The court ruled that although the WAVES mark was pervasive on the Netflix show, it never explicitly or otherwise suggested that it was produced by Pepperdine and the court found no infringement.
In an analogous case that is still ongoing, U.S. Events, LLC v. Detroit Lions, Inc., No. 2:25-cv-14108 (E.D. Mich. filed Dec. 19, 2025), the plaintiff, a Plymouth, Michigan entertainment company that owns the registered “Motor City Muscle” mark, alleged that the Detroit Lions infringed that mark by using “Motor City Muscle” to launch and promote a black alternate uniform. In October 2026 the court issued an order ruling that the team will face a jury trial in 2028 to decide whether the team committed trademark infringement and unfair competition over its use of the mark. Each side now faces years of cost and uncertainty over a question that a mediator drafting a coexistence agreement could answer in a single sitting: can a concert-and-car-show brand and a football team’s uniform share a name if each stays in its own lane? More significantly, how can a professional football team be liable for “unfair competition” with an event promotor? The answer turns on whether customers would likely be confused and a mediator can help the parties test that question quickly and privately, before a judge or jury does it publicly.
How does mediation stack up against the alternatives? Mediation tends to be the quickest, the least expensive and the most private, and it is the only option in which the parties keep control of the result. The tradeoff is that no one can force a deal, so mediation can end without an agreement. But the fallback, whether litigation, arbitration, or a Board proceeding, remains available, and that backup is part of what keeps the talks serious. And when a deal is reached and signed, it is an enforceable contract.
The practical question is whether mediation fits your dispute. Consider it when both sides want to keep operating or if the real question is “can we both fit in this market?” Think twice if you need an immediate court order to stop a clear copycat or want a public ruling to set a precedent.
¹ The form of ACR can vary, but it generally approximates a summary bench trial or cross-motions for summary judgment, with evidentiary submissions that the parties agree to file in lieu of a traditional trial record. If the Board approves trial by ACR, it generally renders a final decision within fifty (50) days following the completion of briefing.
² 827 F. Supp.3d 1316 (C.D. Cal March 31, 2026).
Barbara Mandell is a partner at the firm. She has over 30 years’ experience in complex litigation. Her practice is focused on litigating, arbitrating and counseling her clients on patent, trademark and licensing matters as well as antitrust law.
Related Content from Fishman Stewart
A letter arrives. A lawyer claims that your trademark looks too much like his client’s and demands that you stop. You have spent years building that brand. Now what?
Comerica Park becomes Fifth Third Park in 2027. Here’s how stadium naming rights work as IP licensing and what Fifth Third gains beyond fan approval.
As any trademark lawyer will tell clients considering a rebrand, the adoption of any new trademark involves risk. A search can identify potentially conflicting trademarks that could pose problems for use and/or registration of a new trademark.
Why would the United States grant inventors exclusive rights to their creations while simultaneously seeking to promote competition and innovation? The answer lies in the Patent Act of 1790, which established a framework that still shapes patent law today.
Before a brand makes headlines for the right reasons, it helps to make sure someone else doesn’t already own the name. A recent dispute involving Tesla offers a timely reminder that a great brand name can become an expensive problem.
One second became a surprisingly complicated piece of technology, intellectual property and sports governance in the 2026 collegiate season opening game.
With the end of Hot Dog Season quickly approaching, now is a good time to reflect on the innovative new growth that made this season what it is today.
The Ninth Circuit just reversed course on Jack Daniel's dilution claim against the 'Bad Spaniels' dog toy, vacating the injunction and ruling that parody humor alone doesn't prove reputational harm. Here's what the decision means for brand owners pursuing tarnishment claims.
The trading card industry is booming again - and what makes this moment different is not who holds the cards, literally and figuratively, but how the trading card space is rapidly evolving.
Imagine paying millions of dollars for the naming rights to a stadium—only to have your brand hidden behind a giant white tarp. That’s exactly what happened to Levi Strauss during the 2026 FIFA World Cup.
IDENTIFYING, SECURING AND ADVANCING CREATIVITY®

