Fishman Stewart PLLC | 800 Tower Drive | Suite 610 | Troy, MI 48098 | USA +1 248.594.0600

3Intellectual Property Insights from Fishman Stewart
Newsletter – Volume 26, Issue 23

Share on Social

 

When Monopoly Promotes Progress

By Mark J. Lambrecht

Why would the United States grant inventors exclusive rights to their creations while simultaneously seeking to promote competition and innovation? The answer lies in the Patent Act of 1790, which established a framework that still shapes patent law today. Among other things, this framework relies on three fundamental ideas: exclusive rights, public disclosure, and a limited patent term.

Prior to 1790, patent protection in the US was a regional endeavor. That is, an inventor needed to reach out to their colonial legislature, or later the state legislature, if they sought patent protection. But the hassle did not stop there. This protection only reached to the outer boundaries of the colony or state in question, or sometimes only to regional boundaries within the colony/state. If you wanted protection outside your state, you needed to take it up with each state in which you sought protection. And to complicate things even more, each state had their own unique patent laws and requirements. Inventors and businesses wanted to streamline this process, and politicians listened.

So in 1790, not long after the US Constitution was ratified in 1788, Congress passed the Patent Act and it was signed into law by George Washington, thus giving the federal government the exclusive authority to issue patents. Though since changed, the Act originally established that US patent protection could last up to fourteen (14) years. And this patent protection granted the applicant “sole and exclusive right and liberty of making, constructing, using and vending to others to be used” his or her invention.

Our keen readers may be asking, “What gave the federal government the authority to pass such an Act? Look no further than Article 1, Clause 8 of the US Constitution, which states that Congress has the power to “promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries.” A close reading of clause 8, however, still begs the question, “How does granting an applicant sole and exclusive rights for up to fourteen years (now 20 years) promote the progress of science and useful arts?” This resembles a monopoly, and even our Founders were generally wary of the anticompetitive effects associated with monopolies.

To answer this question, it is helpful to look back at the state of business in 1790. While much has changed in the business world since 1790, much has not. Even back then, there were those intent on capitalizing off of others’ ideas. Suppose Samuel invests substantial time and money developing a better method of producing potash and pearlash. Without patent protection, competitors could simply copy his technique, reducing the incentive to innovate in the first place. If this happens, Samuel is discouraged and others may be as well, wondering what is the point of spending time and money on a new invention if others can simply copy it. 

Well, the Patent Act addressed this concern by granting inventors exclusive rights in their inventions. Now Samuel can get a patent on his potash and pearlash invention so he can stop others from capitalizing on it without his consent. But to ensure that this patent system promoted the progress of science and the useful arts, the 1790 Patent Act also provided a disclosure requirement, stating that the applicant must “describe the said invention or discovery, clearly, truly, and fully.” One theory for the reasoning behind such a requirement is that, by making the public aware of the details of the invention (instead of keeping it secret), the public is given an opportunity to design around the invention. That is, by knowing the details of the invention, someone may develop an alternative solution without infringing the patent.

Taken together, the Patent Act’s exclusive rights and disclosure requirements worked hand in hand. Effectively, there was a quid pro quo that ensured the 1790 Patent Act promoted “the progress of Science and useful Arts.” That is, you may be given exclusive rights on your invention, but you must spill the beans and publicly disclose the secret sauce of your invention (sometimes metaphors should be mixed). The exclusive rights incentivized the citizenry to invent since a patent meant you could exclude others (a.k.a. your competitors) from your invention. This promotes progress, so the argument goes. The exclusive right also incentivizes others to design around patents to avoid infringement prosecution or licensing fees. After all, why pay licensing fees if you can design around the patent. This too promotes progress, so the argument goes. A design-around is not a loophole in patent law, but rather a feature in patent law intended to promote progress.

But what if there was no way to design around a patent? Wouldn’t that stymie, not promote, progress since the 1790 Patent Act allowed an inventor to exclude others from making, constructing, using and vending the invention? Well, that is where the fourteen-year (now twenty-year) time limit comes into play. Once that time passes, the public is free to practice the publicly disclosed invention. Without the patent, the secret invention could remain secret beyond twenty years. But with the patent, the invention is not secret and, after its term limit expires, others are allowed to practice it.

So, working together, the exclusive rights granted to the inventor, the disclosure requirements that benefit the public, and the term limit of the patent promote “the progress of Science and useful Arts.”

Though the Patent Act of 1790 has since been supplanted by subsequent patent acts, it did establish the framework for others to come. Today, we still have a similar disclosure requirement. And this requirement should be well-considered if patent protection is sought. Do you think that someone could easily reverse engineer your invention? If so, patent protection may be what you seek. If your invention can be easily reverse-engineered, there is not much downside to publicly disclosing the details of the invention in a patent. On the other hand, maybe you feel it is unlikely someone will be able to reverse engineer your product or technique within twenty years (the current patent term). If so, maybe it is better to keep the invention a trade secret, foregoing the patent route along with its requirement to disclose the details of your invention to the public.

Mark J. Lambrecht is an Of Counsel patent attorney with Fishman Stewart. His background includes the electrical, electro-mechanical, electro-magnetic, and software/hardware arts.

 
 

Related Content from Fishman Stewart

IDENTIFYING, SECURING AND ADVANCING CREATIVITY®