Intellectual Property Insights from Fishman Stewart PLLC
Newsletter – Volume 25, Issue 12
Share on Social
UPDATE: The Beige Battle Ends in a Whimper, Not a Verdict
In our previous FishTank article “The Great Beige-Off: Influencer Sues for ‘Vibe’ Infringement,” we reported on Sydney Nicole Gifford’s lawsuit against fellow influencer Alyssa Sheil over allegations of copyright infringement involving neutral-toned social media content. As of May 28, 2025, that headline-grabbing case has officially come to a close.
The parties filed a joint stipulation of dismissal with prejudice, ending the case entirely, with no monetary settlement, no confidentiality agreement, and each party covering their own legal costs. According to Sheil’s legal team, this outcome represents a full vindication, with Gifford taking nothing on her claims.
Sheil, who maintained throughout that her “clean girl” aesthetic was independently created, stated that she refused to back down because the case had broader implications for minority entrepreneurs in the influencer space. Her legal team emphasized that this dismissal without conditions or concessions sends a strong message about the limits of copyright protection when it comes to general aesthetics.
While the court never ruled on whether a “beige vibe” is protectable under copyright law, this case leaves behind a clear warning: trying to claim legal ownership over popular visual trends may not pass legal muster, especially when your opponent can show they posted first.
So, who won the title of “Most Basic”? Legally speaking, no one, but Sheil walked away unscathed, and the lawsuit that once promised major precedent now ends with a neutral-toned fade to black.
We’ll continue to monitor developments at the intersection of creativity, commerce, and copyright. Stay tuned.
Michelle Visser is a partner of Fishman Stewart, with over 25 years of experience practicing trademark law with other members of the firm’s Trademark Group. Check out her full bio here.
Related Content from Fishman Stewart
In recent years, companies have gravitated toward a visual trend: the minimalist logo. While some critics dismiss the trend, the shift toward minimalism is rooted in something else other than fashion.
When the Oakland Athletics announced plans to relocate to Las Vegas in 2028, many fans were excited. But the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) recently threw a curveball by refusing the team’s trademark applications for “Las Vegas Athletics” and “Vegas Athletics.”
Advances in molecular biology have an uncanny knack of doing two things at once: saving lives and giving U.S. patent law a persistent headache.
Artificial Christmas trees have become an enduring symbol of holiday cheer, blending tradition with innovation. Today, they are celebrated for their convenience, sustainability, and versatility, but their story began centuries ago as a creative solution to environmental and safety concerns.
Doosan Bobcat North America filed federal and international lawsuits against Caterpillar alleging Caterpillar improperly reverse engineered loader components.
Nothing warms the holiday spirit quite like a copyright lawsuit over a light-up reindeer. Back in 2019, two companies went head-to-head over just that when Enchant sued Glowco for copyright infringement.
The real tech revolution in sports right now is being powered by AI that uses data from wearable sensors - and crunches numbers faster than any coach with a clipboard could.
The real tech revolution in sports right now is being powered by AI that uses data from wearable sensors - and crunches numbers faster than any coach with a clipboard could.
If your inbox has been serving up dramatic “copyright infringement” cease and desist letters lately, you’re not imagining it. Scam C&Ds are having a moment.
In British and American culture, finding a penny is traditionally considered to be sign of luck - but how long until we stop finding them altogether?
IDENTIFYING, SECURING AND ADVANCING CREATIVITY®
