Intellectual Property Insights from Fishman Stewart PLLC
Newsletter – Volume 25, Issue 12
Share on Social
UPDATE: The Beige Battle Ends in a Whimper, Not a Verdict
In our previous FishTank article “The Great Beige-Off: Influencer Sues for ‘Vibe’ Infringement,” we reported on Sydney Nicole Gifford’s lawsuit against fellow influencer Alyssa Sheil over allegations of copyright infringement involving neutral-toned social media content. As of May 28, 2025, that headline-grabbing case has officially come to a close.
The parties filed a joint stipulation of dismissal with prejudice, ending the case entirely, with no monetary settlement, no confidentiality agreement, and each party covering their own legal costs. According to Sheil’s legal team, this outcome represents a full vindication, with Gifford taking nothing on her claims.
Sheil, who maintained throughout that her “clean girl” aesthetic was independently created, stated that she refused to back down because the case had broader implications for minority entrepreneurs in the influencer space. Her legal team emphasized that this dismissal without conditions or concessions sends a strong message about the limits of copyright protection when it comes to general aesthetics.
While the court never ruled on whether a “beige vibe” is protectable under copyright law, this case leaves behind a clear warning: trying to claim legal ownership over popular visual trends may not pass legal muster, especially when your opponent can show they posted first.
So, who won the title of “Most Basic”? Legally speaking, no one, but Sheil walked away unscathed, and the lawsuit that once promised major precedent now ends with a neutral-toned fade to black.
We’ll continue to monitor developments at the intersection of creativity, commerce, and copyright. Stay tuned.
Michelle Visser is a partner of Fishman Stewart, with over 25 years of experience practicing trademark law with other members of the firm’s Trademark Group. Check out her full bio here.
Related Content from Fishman Stewart
The Ninth Circuit just reversed course on Jack Daniel's dilution claim against the 'Bad Spaniels' dog toy, vacating the injunction and ruling that parody humor alone doesn't prove reputational harm. Here's what the decision means for brand owners pursuing tarnishment claims.
The trading card industry is booming again - and what makes this moment different is not who holds the cards, literally and figuratively, but how the trading card space is rapidly evolving.
Imagine paying millions of dollars for the naming rights to a stadium—only to have your brand hidden behind a giant white tarp. That’s exactly what happened to Levi Strauss during the 2026 FIFA World Cup.
As we celebrate our nation’s birthday on July 4th, many communities are replacing or supplementing traditional fireworks with drone-based light shows - which prompts the question of intellectual property protection.
The fun internet trend of promoting "dupes" has officially crossed the trademark line and everyday content creators are finding themselves in the crosshairs of multimillion-dollar corporate lawsuits.
The FIFA World Cup is global football (or soccer) at its highest level. It is, however, also one of the most carefully crafted displays of intellectual property (IP) in the world.
Trademark owners are often cast as villains when they send cease-and-desist letters. But in trademark law, failing to enforce rights can sometimes create bigger problems than enforcing them.
Women’s sports are having a moment, and not a small one. And right alongside that rise: the business of women’s sports is heating up, including some surprisingly dramatic trademark battles.
The idea that someone might “own” a piece of DNA raises a slightly uncomfortable question: can you really patent something that exists inside all of us?
Forbes reported that more than 1.5 million bots on an AI agent-driven social network appear to have created a new religion for themselves, the Church of Molt, with congregants adopting the name of “Crustafarians.”
IDENTIFYING, SECURING AND ADVANCING CREATIVITY®
