Intellectual Property Insights from Fishman Stewart
Newsletter – Volume 25, Issue 22
Share on Social
The Curse of the Co-Owner: A Haunting Tale of Trademark Ownership
In the spirit of Halloween, here’s a real-life ghost story from the world of trademark law. No haunted mansions, no cursed amulets—just a trademark co-ownership arrangement gone frighteningly wrong.
In Reed v. Marshall, the R&B group JADE—known for their early 1990s hits—found themselves in a chilling trademark dispute decades later. Former bandmates fought over who had the right to use the group’s registered trademark, JADE, after the group’s heyday. After a failed reunion attempt, one member claimed that the others’ continued performances under “JADE” violated her trademark rights. The court, however, delivered a ruling that would make any brand owner’s blood run cold.
The Fifth Circuit confirmed that each co-owner of a trademark has equal rights to use the mark unless an agreement says otherwise. That means one owner cannot stop another from using it—even in direct competition. Without a written contract, each co-owner can act independently, leaving the mark vulnerable to inconsistent use, brand dilution, or worse—public confusion.
As the court reminded us, the Lanham Act won’t put these trademark ghosts to rest. Absent an agreement, co-owners are stuck sharing the mark, whether they like it or not.
The moral of this spooky tale? Never share a mark without setting boundaries in writing. A simple agreement outlining who can use the mark, under what conditions, who controls quality standards, and what happens when one party exists the arrangement can save years of haunting litigation. Fail to do so, and you may find yourself watching your brand take on a life—or an afterlife—of its own.
In the realm of trademarks, the real monsters aren’t trolls or counterfeiters. They’re trademark disputes you can’t fight. So, trademark owners take heed. Before you collaborate, license, or co-own a mark, cover your assets with a written agreement and avoid becoming a ghost story waiting to happen.
Benjamin Becker is an Associate with Fishman Stewart PLLC, specializing in intellectual property law. Ben focuses on trademark law, providing comprehensive services including foreign and domestic prosecution, agreements, negotiations, assignments, and enforcement.
Related Content from Fishman Stewart
In British and American culture, finding a penny is traditionally considered to be sign of luck - but how long until we stop finding them altogether?
If you're planning a magic show, be careful if you invoke the name of the great Houdini... you may need more than trick handcuffs to escape an infringement lawsuit.
Costumes, masks, vampires, and candy corn are symbols of Halloween. But can anyone own rights to these icons of fright and festivity?
They say she watches. That her eyes glow red at midnight. That if you sit on her lap, you’ll never rise again. She’s called Black Aggie, and she wasn’t supposed to exist.
Read about a haunting trademark co-ownership arrangement gone frighteningly wrong.
Cracker Barrel learned an important lesson with their recent logo rebranding campaign.
A Lima, OH woman turned the tables on a local car dealership after her vehicle was repossessed—by legally claiming the dealership’s name.
Trademark owners are advised to conduct searches for translations of any foreign terms in their proposed marks before selection to avoid this faux pas.
If you recently got a copyright registration certificate in the mail and noticed it’s missing something kind of important—like a signature—you’re not imagining things.
In the fast-paced world of fashion, IP Rights are often overlooked—yet they can be a game changer. From trademarks that protect brand identity to copyrights for original prints, IP Rights offer critical tools for protecting both creativity and market value.
IDENTIFYING, SECURING AND ADVANCING CREATIVITY®
