Intellectual Property Insights from Fishman Stewart
Mini Article – Volume 24, Issue 5
Share on Social
More than One Way to Slice a Potato?
By Kristyn Webb
The dispute began in 2016 when chip-maker Simplot sued rival chip-maker McCain, alleging that McCain’s spiral-cut “Twisted Potato” design infringed Simplot’s design patent US D640036 for a “Spiral Potato Piece.” A few months later, McCain counter sued alleging that Simplot’s spiral-cut “Sidewinders” infringed McCains’ design patent US D720916 for a “Root Vegetable Product.” McCain also alleged that Simplot’s chips infringed its utility patent US 6821540 for a “Process for Treating Vegetables and Fruit Before Cooking” involving the use of a “pulse electric field” to soften fruits and vegetables before they are cut.
Fast forward several years, and after numerous motions, responses, and replies, to January 2024: the court hearing the case in Idaho (the potato capital of the world), has denied the parties’ cross-motions for summary judgment, and concluded that the case should go to trial.
The ‘540 patent refers to passing an electric current through the fruit or vegetable before cutting and cooking. The parties disagree about whether Simplot’s method of partially heating the potatoes in oil (“parfrying”) falls within the meaning of “cooking” or whether the patent only covers products that are totally cooked and ready to eat.
Regarding the competing design patents, the court concluded that it was best left for a jury to decide whether the parties’ respective design patents and the accused products are similar enough for any findings of infringement. So, after several years of litigation, 120 docket entries, and a 141-page ruling, it appears the case is (finally) headed to trial. We hope the jury will at least get a chance to sample the accused products!
Kristyn Webb is the Group Leader of Fishman Stewart’s Copyright Practice Group, and holds a Master’s Degree in Copyright Law from King’s College London.
Published March 22, 2024
Related Content from Fishman Stewart
First, a big “thank you” to all our readers who have given feedback on our newsletter. We appreciate your interest and insights. It is always a treat to hear from you! Second, we wanted to provide you with updates on some of our most popular articles
“Palworld”— a computer game created and published by Japanese developer Pocket Pair. Released as an early access game in January 2024, it sold over seven million copies on the computer platform Steam in the first five days and had nearly 20 million players in the first two weeks.
This year’s Super Bowl featured a thrilling overtime victory for the Kansas City Chiefs over the San Francisco 49ers. With estimates as high as 123 million viewers, America's premier sporting event also serves as a grand stage for creativity and intellectual property protections that enhance the game’s success.
Valentine’s Day is just around the corner and jewelry sales are usually around $6 billion USD in the United States alone. In 2021, the US Customs and Border Protection agency seized over $1 billion USD worth of counterfeit pieces of jewelry.
Detroit Lions In Copyright Dispute Over Barry Sanders Statue
Fish Tank: Newsletter Volume 24, Issue 3
This season marked many ‘firsts’ for the Lions including unveiling the first statue at Ford Field immortalizing a former Lion: Barry Sanders. However, some may not consider the Sanders statue a clear ‘win’ for the Detroit Lions franchise.
A few years ago, the Copyright Office received a large number of requests from Twilight fans who wanted to get a peek at the registered and unpublished manuscript of Stephanie Meyer’s Forever Dawn.
Demetrious Polychron was a big fan of The Lord of the Rings books by author J.R.R. Tolkien, which described the world of Middle Earth where Hobbits, Elves, Dwarves, Wizards, and other creatures engage in an epic battle of good and evil involving a ring with magical powers.
Public Domain Day is celebrated on January 1st and commemorates the expiration of copyright protection for certain creative works.
Taylor Swift has had an incredible 2023. Her “Eras Tour” has been a massive success, becoming one of the most profitable tours for an artist of all time. The release of the concert film of the tour became the highest-grossing concert film of all time.
Why is IP Protection Crucial for Small Businesses? We understand the challenges faced by small businesses, and we encourage you to take proactive measures to protect your intellectual property.
IDENTIFYING, SECURING AND ADVANCING CREATIVITY®
