Intellectual Property Insights from Fishman Stewart
Mini Article – Volume 23, Issue 8
Share on Social
Tax Loopholes and Lox: How a Cream Cheese-Stuffed Bagel Exposed a Delicious Sandwich-Tax Loophole
By Kristyn Webb
Inventors and designers have the challenging job of inventing and designing around many issues: prior art, competitive products, budgets, physics, consumer safety, market demand, supply chain hiccups, government regulations, and … taxes.
One bagel shop in New York has innovated its way around the state’s so-called sandwich tax, which adds approximately a 9% sales tax on anything that qualifies as a “sandwich.” New York’s Department of Taxation and Finance bulletin includes several suprising food items that fall into this category, like burritos, hot dogs, open-faced sandwiches, and buttered bagels. However, an unsliced and undressed bagel is not considered a “sandwich” subject to sales tax.
During Tax Season, H&H Bagels teamed up with cream cheese maker Philadelphia® to create the “Tax-Free Bagel”—an unsliced, unschmeared, H&H bagel filled with Philadelphia cream cheese. The cream cheese is injected into the bagel the way that jelly or custard is put into a filled donut. Think: stuffed-crust pizza, but with a bagel and cream cheese. Reviews have been mixed. Some consumers find the product too unconventional to be a true “New York style bagel” while others like the taste of a tax loophole.
We will see if other food establishments take similar measures to design around the tax code. Perhaps deconstructed burritos will never be a hit, but could hot dog stands start marketing hot dogs with buns sold separately?
Kristyn Webb is the Group Leader of Fishman Stewart’s Copyright Practice Group, and is currently earning a Master’s Degree in Copyright Law at King’s College London.
Published April 21, 2023
Related Content from Fishman Stewart
In British and American culture, finding a penny is traditionally considered to be sign of luck - but how long until we stop finding them altogether?
If you're planning a magic show, be careful if you invoke the name of the great Houdini... you may need more than trick handcuffs to escape an infringement lawsuit.
Costumes, masks, vampires, and candy corn are symbols of Halloween. But can anyone own rights to these icons of fright and festivity?
They say she watches. That her eyes glow red at midnight. That if you sit on her lap, you’ll never rise again. She’s called Black Aggie, and she wasn’t supposed to exist.
Read about a haunting trademark co-ownership arrangement gone frighteningly wrong.
Cracker Barrel learned an important lesson with their recent logo rebranding campaign.
A Lima, OH woman turned the tables on a local car dealership after her vehicle was repossessed—by legally claiming the dealership’s name.
Trademark owners are advised to conduct searches for translations of any foreign terms in their proposed marks before selection to avoid this faux pas.
If you recently got a copyright registration certificate in the mail and noticed it’s missing something kind of important—like a signature—you’re not imagining things.
In the fast-paced world of fashion, IP Rights are often overlooked—yet they can be a game changer. From trademarks that protect brand identity to copyrights for original prints, IP Rights offer critical tools for protecting both creativity and market value.
IDENTIFYING, SECURING AND ADVANCING CREATIVITY®
