Intellectual Property Insights from Fishman Stewart PLLC
Newsletter – Volume 22, Issue 21
Share on Social
COPY AND PASTE? NOT SO FAST. Some Copyright Caution.
By: Julie A. Greenberg
Have you read an interesting article or social media post that just “speaks to you” – saying exactly what you want to say yourself, or proving a point you really want to make? If so, you may have wanted to “copy and paste” that article, or even a portion of it. But heed this warning: copyright law (literally the law governing the “right to copy”) has some prohibitions you should know about.
In the United States, and in many other countries, copyright protection arises at the moment a work is fixed in tangible medium. This means, for example, that you have rights as soon as you write a poem with a pen on paper, save a typed letter to your computer hard drive, record a song on tape, paint on canvas, sculpt in marble, or snap a photograph on your mobile phone. A work is protected by copyright automatically: the author need not file for protection with the government to protect a work.
It is advisable to assume that copyright law applies – no matter the nature of the work – and do not copy any of this into your own work, your own article, or your own social media post, without permission of the owner. Permission is very often given – authors are often flattered to be asked. Don’t be shy about asking.
U.S. copyright law grants the owner of copyright in a work the exclusive rights to reproduce and publicly distribute, perform and display the work, among other rights. All copying is covered – even downloading a copy onto your computer may constitute an unauthorized copy. Further, there is no “social media” exception to these rights, although some social media platforms may include a license in their terms of service which permits “sharing” and “retweeting” certain content within the platform. While “retweeting” and “sharing” may be permitted, you should be careful what you post and share. Social media posts and tweets are protected by copyright law just like everything else, so be careful before “embedding” content created by others into your own work outside of the platform. Also, “retweeting” or “sharing” someone else’s already infringing work might make you an infringer too.
Further, copying with attribution is not a loophole that avoids copyright infringement. In fact, providing attribution may complicate matters because it may be used as evidence that your copying was willful or intentional, which could subject you to higher penalties and damages in an infringement lawsuit. However, some works that are protected by copyright and made available for public use require that you provide proper attribution. For example, Creative Commons licenses often include a condition that requires the user to give proper credit, a link to the license, and indicate if any changes were made to the original work.
Finally, be wary of the murky area of “fair use.” While certain copying can avoid claims of copyright infringement if they fall under the umbrella of “fair use,” whether or not a copying is “fair use” is extremely uncertain, unpredictable, and ultimately can only be determined by a federal court. That’s not generally worth the risk.
With all that said, you may now be thinking, “So how can one safely refer to another’s work?” The best practice is to put the idea into your own words and provide a link to the original source. For example, you could write “Jane Goodall’s observations led to the discovery that chimps are omnivorous rather than vegetarian. See, https://www.janegoodall.org/our-story/our-legacy-of-science.” This is always a safe plan: linking to a work without quoting it is not copyright infringement.
Bottom line: Be cautious, and when in doubt, seek the author’s permission. If you find yourself wondering if something is protected by copyright law, please contact us, and we would be happy to advise.
Julie Greenberg is a Partner at Fishman Stewart and has more than 30 years of experience protecting and defending her clients’ valuable trademarks and copyrights at all levels, including in infringement matters worldwide, and in particular at the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) and the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board.
Published October 14, 2022
Measures To Protect Intellectual Property Rights On Social Media
Having a robust social media presence is vital for modern businesses. But how do you protect your copyrights and trademarks against theft and impersonation online?
Fishman Stewart Sponsors ESD’s Student Writing Contest Scholarship
Fishman Stewart PLLC is proud to sponsor a $1,000 scholarship for the winner of The Engineering Society of Detroit’s (ESD) Engineering Student Writing Contest. The contest was created in an effort to promote and engage student voices and ideas about the profession of engineering.
The contest is now open to all students attending accredited Michigan universities and studying within any of the engineering disciplines or related technical and scientific fields. The top three entries will be published in the January 2023 issue of the ESD’s TechCentury magazine. The top award-winning essay author will receive recognition at the 2023 ESD Gold Award Reception and a $1,000 scholarship sponsored by Fishman Stewart.
Click here for more information about the Engineering Student Writing Contest and to download the contest entry form.
Related Content from Fishman Stewart
People are familiar with the most famous examples of trademarks which have been “lost”—or almost lost.
If you are looking to capitalize on the NCAA tournament, make sure to draw up your promotional play with a trademark attorney beforehand.
This practice is often called the “Poor Man’s Copyright” and the idea has been around for a long time. The theory is that mailing a copy of a work to yourself will provide you with certain legal rights akin to a copyright registration so long as the envelope remains sealed and bears a postmark by the United States Postal Service.
Public Domain Day is celebrated on January 1st and commemorates the expiration of copyright protection for certain creative works. US copyright law provides the copyright owner with certain exclusive rights for a limited time, after which the works fall into the public domain.
Unlike the Matrix, Star Wars, and Austin Powers, respectively, Chat Generative Pre-trained Transformer, or ChatGPT, is not a robot in disguise or a bot of science fiction. We, the users, provide prompts in text form, and ChatGPT converses in response to the prompts.
Mariah Carey filed a U.S. trademark application attempting to claim trademark rights to “QUEEN OF CHRISTMAS” for a wide range of different goods and services including alcoholic beverages, online retail services, dog collars, musical recordings, body lotions, spa items, Christmas decorations, and even lactose-free milk.
Recently, we filed an application to register the copyright for Finny the Fish. In the United States, and in many other countries, copyright protection arises at the moment a work is fixed in tangible medium. So, why would we take the extra step to register Finny’s copyright?
With the 2022 midterms (almost) in the rearview mirror, political junkies are now free to turn their full attention to the 2024 presidential election. Today’s focus is on the tug of war that can occur when candidates play music at campaign events.
Both trademark law and copyright law may protect your logo, although the protection they provide differs. Trademark law would prohibit the unauthorized use of another’s logo that is sufficiently similar to your logo such that it is likely to cause confusion in the marketplace.
In the U.S., copyright protection generally does not extend to “useful” articles, like shoes, but can protect the designs on shoes, like that of the Yeezy Boost 350 sneakers. However, in Italy, the global fashion powerhouse since the 15th century, copyright law can protect shoes—like Moon Boots.
IDENTIFYING, SECURING AND ADVANCING CREATIVITY®
