Fishman Stewart PLLC | 800 Tower Drive | Suite 610 | Troy, MI 48098 | USA +1 248.594.0600

Intellectual Property Insights from Fishman Stewart
Mini Article – Volume 23, Issue 4

Share on Social

 

AI Stands for … Art Infringers?

By Alexander JSW Johnson

Artificial Intelligence tools have been all the rage in recent months. From ChatGPT to Midjourney, these tools take different forms but the premise is the same: a user enters a prompt in text form, and the AI tool creates a response in text-form or image. They do so by learning from existing writings and images and then composing a piece based on all those reference points. They can even write or render in the particular style of a person, genre, period, or other style-defining category.

Last month, a trio of artists filed a class action suit against three AI tool-makers: Stability AI Ltd. (and Stability AI), Inc., Midjourney, Inc., and DeviantArt, Inc. The thrust: these tools create works (text or images) taking the style of or sourcing from copyrighted works without permission.

I’m not here to weigh in on this suit (particularly the class certification angle), but, I do find it interesting and noteworthy that in my undergrad art studies, instructors often encouraged studying the classics and practicing replication of specific pieces down to every detail imaginable as a means of developing skill—but the works I trained on were always public domain pieces. The pieces that these AI tools have drawn on for training their skills and creating their pieces are, at least in some instances, not public domain.

This case draws out some interesting issues for AI-generated artwork.  First, do these AI art bots “copy” works such that it is copyright infringement, or is it fair use as inspirational source material? Second, regardless of infringement and fair use, are the works of these AI tools copyrightable works themselves?

Last month I asked for your take on who owns the copyright in user-prompted, AI-generated text. After considering the issue for a different medium—visual works—I’m curious what your view is now.

Who owns the copyright in works generated by AI tools?


 
To talk trademarks, bots, and technology, contact Alex at ajohnson@fishstewip.com, 248-594-0614, or find him on LinkedIn.
 
Alexander JSW Johnson is an attorney at Fishman Stewart with nearly a decade of experience in trademark and intellectual property matters. He works in the firm’s Trademark Practice Group. He holds a B.A. in Art (studio emphasis) and Journalism. Check out his full bio here.
 

Published February 23, 2023

Related Content from Fishman Stewart

<a class="eael-grid-post-link" href="https://fishstewip.com/pokemon-vs-palworld-the-poke-ball-is-in-nintendos-courtfish-tank-newsletter-volume-24-issue-5/" title="Pokémon vs. Palworld – The Poké Ball is in Nintendo’s Court

Fish Tank: Newsletter Volume 24, Issue 5
">Pokémon vs. Palworld – The Poké Ball is in Nintendo’s Court
Fish Tank: Newsletter Volume 24, Issue 5

“Palworld”— a computer game created and published by Japanese developer Pocket Pair. Released as an early access game in January 2024, it sold over seven million copies on the computer platform Steam in the first five days and had nearly 20 million players in the first two weeks.

Read More

<a class="eael-grid-post-link" href="https://fishstewip.com/intellectual-propertys-role-in-shaping-the-super-bowl-experiencefish-tank-newsletter-volume-24-issue-4/" title="Intellectual Property’s Role in Shaping the Super Bowl Experience

Fish Tank: Newsletter Volume 24, Issue 4
">Intellectual Property’s Role in Shaping the Super Bowl Experience
Fish Tank: Newsletter Volume 24, Issue 4

This year’s Super Bowl featured a thrilling overtime victory for the Kansas City Chiefs over the San Francisco 49ers. With estimates as high as 123 million viewers, America's premier sporting event also serves as a grand stage for creativity and intellectual property protections that enhance the game’s success.

Read More

<a class="eael-grid-post-link" href="https://fishstewip.com/if-you-like-then-you-shoulda-put-a-c-on-it-fishbits-mini-article-volume-24-issue-3/" title="If You Like It Then You Shoulda Put a © on It. 

FishBits: Mini Article Volume 24, Issue 3
">If You Like It Then You Shoulda Put a © on It. 
FishBits: Mini Article Volume 24, Issue 3

Valentine’s Day is just around the corner and jewelry sales are usually around $6 billion USD in the United States alone. In 2021, the US Customs and Border Protection agency seized over $1 billion USD worth of counterfeit pieces of jewelry.

Read More

<a class="eael-grid-post-link" href="https://fishstewip.com/detroit-lions-in-copyright-dispute-over-barry-sanders-statuefish-tank-newsletter-volume-24-issue-3/" title="Detroit Lions In Copyright Dispute Over Barry Sanders Statue

Fish Tank: Newsletter Volume 24, Issue 3
">Detroit Lions In Copyright Dispute Over Barry Sanders Statue
Fish Tank: Newsletter Volume 24, Issue 3

This season marked many ‘firsts’ for the Lions including unveiling the first statue at Ford Field immortalizing a former Lion: Barry Sanders. However, some may not consider the Sanders statue a clear ‘win’ for the Detroit Lions franchise.

Read More

<a class="eael-grid-post-link" href="https://fishstewip.com/who-can-read-my-manuscript-fishbits-mini-article-volume-24-issue-2/" title="Who Can Read My Manuscript? 

FishBits: Mini Article Volume 24, Issue 2
">Who Can Read My Manuscript? 
FishBits: Mini Article Volume 24, Issue 2

A few years ago, the Copyright Office received a large number of requests from Twilight fans who wanted to get a peek at the registered and unpublished manuscript of Stephanie Meyer’s Forever Dawn.

Read More

<a class="eael-grid-post-link" href="https://fishstewip.com/the-fellowship-of-fandom-fishbits-mini-article-volume-24-issue-1/" title="The Fellowship of Fandom 

FishBits: Mini Article Volume 24, Issue 1
">The Fellowship of Fandom 
FishBits: Mini Article Volume 24, Issue 1

Demetrious Polychron was a big fan of The Lord of the Rings books by author J.R.R. Tolkien, which described the world of Middle Earth where Hobbits, Elves, Dwarves, Wizards, and other creatures engage in an epic battle of good and evil involving a ring with magical powers.

Read More

<a class="eael-grid-post-link" href="https://fishstewip.com/countdown-to-public-domain-dayfishbits-mini-article-volume-23-issue-23/" title="Countdown to Public Domain Day

FishBits: Mini Article Volume 23, Issue 23
">Countdown to Public Domain Day
FishBits: Mini Article Volume 23, Issue 23

Public Domain Day is celebrated on January 1st and commemorates the expiration of copyright protection for certain creative works.

Read More

<a class="eael-grid-post-link" href="https://fishstewip.com/taylor-swift-david-versus-goliathfish-tank-newsletter-volume-23-issue-27/" title="Taylor Swift: David versus Goliath

Fish Tank: Newsletter Volume 23, Issue 27
">Taylor Swift: David versus Goliath
Fish Tank: Newsletter Volume 23, Issue 27

Taylor Swift has had an incredible 2023. Her “Eras Tour” has been a massive success, becoming one of the most profitable tours for an artist of all time. The release of the concert film of the tour became the highest-grossing concert film of all time.

Read More

<a class="eael-grid-post-link" href="https://fishstewip.com/happy-small-business-saturdayfishbits-mini-article-volume-23-issue-22/" title="Happy Small Business Saturday!

FishBits: Mini Article Volume 23, Issue 22
">Happy Small Business Saturday!
FishBits: Mini Article Volume 23, Issue 22

Why is IP Protection Crucial for Small Businesses? We understand the challenges faced by small businesses, and we encourage you to take proactive measures to protect your intellectual property.

Read More

<a class="eael-grid-post-link" href="https://fishstewip.com/queen-of-christmas-sued-for-copyright-infringement-againfishbits-mini-article-volume-23-issue-21/" title="Queen of Christmas Sued for Copyright Infringement – Again

FishBits: Mini Article Volume 23, Issue 21
">Queen of Christmas Sued for Copyright Infringement – Again
FishBits: Mini Article Volume 23, Issue 21

Earlier this month, Mariah Carey was named in a lawsuit in federal district court for copyright infringement. The plaintiffs, musicians Andy Stone (stage name “Vince Vance”) and Troy Powers, allege that the so-called “Queen of Christmas” used their country music song “All I want for Christmas is You” as the basis for her hit pop song with the same title.

Read More

IDENTIFYING, SECURING AND ADVANCING CREATIVITY®